can little kids even take a sigg of water?

The first time that I’ve ever written about a product that I hadn’t actually used before was when I wrote of my shopping spree for Sigg bottles for my girls. You know, the whole “out with the bad and in with the green” craze that occurred in my kitchen a couple of weeks ago? I was doing some reading about the potential dangers in the plastics of a good portion of the plastic food-related items on the market for our kids, cleaning out drawers filled to the brim with plastic cups, utensils, plates. You name it. It went into the plastic recycling bin.

And then, I spent a sizable amount of money on four Sigg bottles. Two for each of the girls. I’d done all of my research and chose the smaller size as a sippy cup alternative for Coco and the middle size for Pea as an alternative to a bottle of water in her lunch sac at camp this summer. And the bottles arrived. And yes, they are gorgeous. And certainly, they are super-awesome for the environment. And while I appreciate beautiful things and definitely want to be gentler on Mother Earth, I also know that my youngest? She needs a fork-lift to raise that bottle to her lips. And Pea? While I like to think she’s a fairly mature preschooler, she’s still a kid. And kids drop stuff. And when a kid drops a Sigg cup with the flip-top cap? The cap snaps off, particularly when the cap is in the “open” position, which it would naturally be in if a child were using the cup for it’s intended purpose. Seriously, I’ve yet to meet a kid, a small kid, who puts a cap back on anything. If you have one of those, consider yourself quite fortunate. Because I do not. And so… I watched in slow motion as her Sigg cup tumbled out of my husband’s huge SUV and onto the pavement. And snap! Off with the cap!

I was devastated. How ridiculous is that? It’s a bottle. A bottle! But it was a pricy one. And I mourned the flip-top cap of that bottle the entire ride home. And then? Upon our arrival, my mother came into the kitchen and asked for a bottle to fill with water. She and her fiance were going on a hike. And I thought aha! She can use one of Pea’s Sigg bottles! Perfect! It’s not a total waste. And I filled it up with water, handed it to her and she left.

After a few minutes, I looked out a window in the front of the house, and what did I see? My mother, decanting the water from the toddler Sigg bottle into a plastic bottle. Uh… This cup is apparently too heavy even for a grown-up?

Well, after much digging around this morning, during Coco’s nap-time, you can imagine how pleasantly surprised I was to learn that Gerber is actually at the forefront, leading the pack of mass-produced baby product companies, in cleaning up the materials that they use to produce their myriad baby products. Gerber! Gerber equates to so reasonably priced in my household that I can literally buy three 2-packs of their cups for the price of 1 of those darned Sigg bottles that are resting quietly in a drawer in my kitchen, one of them sadly decapitated. I think they will be there for quite some time, mocking me in all of their self-righteous Swiss-engineered continuous-piece-of-aluminum smugness…

I’m sticking with these cups by Gerber, which you can find at your neighborhood grocery store, just as I did this morning. And these by Nuby, which you can find at your local Target. And if you have a younger baby in need of a cup with a handle? Check this one out, also by Nuby. I’ve learned my lesson from the Great Sigg Kid’s Bottle Fiasco of 2008. Look before you leap…

17

comments

17 Comments on “can little kids even take a sigg of water?”

  1. erin said:

    Got these Nuby cups and love them! Glad you found them and shared!

  2. Jaina said:

    That’s disappointing, you were so excited about those Siggs. At least you found a good alternative. Does the Sigg company have any sort of satisfaction return policy? I would totally return them and get a refund if they do. Or write a letter of complaint.

  3. Melissa the Mouth said:

    Christie,

    Thanks! Here’s the link for my RSS feed:

    http://melissathemouth.com/?feed=rss2

  4. christie said:

    Sorry to do this via comment, but… I found you via a Google Ad, of all things, and I really like your site. Do you have an RSS feed operating? Thanks!

  5. Melissa the Mouth said:

    Abi,

    We were fortunate in our home to skip right over the bottles with both of our girls. They went right from nursing to sippy cups. But that doesn’t mean the transition was easy! Pea had an especially tough time getting the hang of the cup, and I thought she was NEVER going to get it! Of course, she did. And so with Coco, we started her even earlier, hoping that it wouldn’t be so foreign when it was time to make the switch, at one. And it worked. Honestly, we just had to, with BOTH girls, keep trying different cups until we found the ones that each liked best. It turned out they both liked the Gerber with handles. Good news is 1) it’s cheap and 2) it’s BPA-free. Not bad, right?

    Good luck to you! And my only advice? Introduce the sippy sooner, rather than later. Fill it with water and prepare to laugh a lot…

  6. Abi said:

    Thanks for the links for sippy cup alternatives. My daughter just turned one a few weeks ago and we are now starting to transition from bottle to sippy cup but she will have none of it. She doesn’t even want the sippy cup near her face. How did you get your kids to switch from bottle to sippy cup?

  7. Monica said:

    Hmm…It is great to have a family source who has some experience in plastics, but I think I’ll go on the safe side and steer clear of items made of PVC and containing BPA. I feel more cautious than hysterical.

    We have all of the green sippy cups from Sigg to Born Free. Sadly she usually wants to drink out of the bright bottle of her friend. Arent we all attracted to bright toxins…oooo pretty cake …. oooo pretty cosmo.

    Here are a few options frequently seen in San Francisco and the East Bay:

    Kleen Kanteen which are stainless steel (so you dont have to wonder about the secret ingredients in the Sigg bottle liner). They are heavier than SIgg. My 23 month old loves hers, no problem with drinking out of it. It is harder to ding up than the Sigg. You can find them on REI. They are about to add colors to their line, so the smaller “sippy cup” version is on back order at many places.

    Foogo sippy cup. They have straws and are super cute!

    Born Free. They leak. A lot. We have several anyway.

  8. Meaghan said:

    Thank you for letting us know about the Siggs! I was drawn in by their insanely cute designs, but I have to say…. I believe this BPA thing is being blown WAY out of proportion. My father is a materials engineer who specializes in plastics, and I naturally turn to him for information when I read about “plastics/chemicals that are killing our babies” (which is terrifying). For BPA to leech, it has to be above 300 degrees Fahrenheit for over 3 hours. NOTHING I give my child will be that hot for that long. He said that if we want to be concerned, we should worry about plasticizers that are in soft plastics (like rubber ducks). AND that the biggest risk rubber ducks (and their counterparts) pose to the environment is when they are burned (which may happen when we throw them out). My point? It is really easy to allow the media to spin science, esp. when our children’s safety is at risk. I am doing my part to try to put an end to hysteria and fear mongering (from the media, not you, Melissa) because if another one of my single friends sends me an email forward about BPA- cancer, formaldehyde cribs or dry drownings, I just might lose it. It’s hard enough to raise a kid without worrying that we are giving them cancer with a water bottle. (For scientific proof that is lay-person friendly, go the the avent website, where they address the BPA issue. Please, don’t just take my word for it.)

  9. Shannon (Cole Mine) said:

    We use these Gerber cups and have been very happy with them. I was glad to read about your fiasco b/c I was just about to order some SIGGs for my son’s preschool debut. Now I’ll look elsewhere. Thanks!

  10. the mama bird diaries said:

    i found the Sigg cups just too heavy overall and didn’t hold enough water. i try to be very green but also switched to other BPA free straw cups.

  11. Melissa the Mouth said:

    Liz,

    Yes, the Gerber cups are BPA-free. In fact, it seems most of the Gerber products for babies and toddlers are. Surprised, right? Be careful on the Amazon site, because when something says it’s BPA-free, it’s being noted as such by shoppers, so a lot of that stuff on there is not actually BPA-free. I’ve spent countless hours over the past week researching this stuff. The best and most comprehensive information I found, in one place, that was easy to understand was on a site called “Z Recommends.” The link is http://zrecs.blogspot.com/

    Happy shopping!

  12. Liz said:

    I bought my son two Born Free sippy cups which are BPA free, but they are about $10 apiece. I’m glad cheaper alternatives are coming out – and at Target no less!

    Melissa – are the Gerber ones BPA free? The page on Amazon didn’t say…

  13. Belle said:

    You can purchase replacement caps for Sigg bottles.

  14. Everyday Yogini said:

    I have to tell you, I was given a Sigg bottle as a gift. I can’t stand it. I will be replacing our bottles with BPA free nalgene bottles. I am so sorry about the disappointing purchase…

  15. Kristi said:

    Careful of the Nuby no handle one. My daughter LOVES having a sippy cup in with her at night. I left that one in one night and heard (at 3am) “uh oh, water water water” Apparently the lid twists of very very easy and she had dumped water all over herself and her crib (she’s 18 months). Our daycare uses these as well and have had the same problem with some of the kids who are 2+

  16. Dancer said:

    Nalgene also has a BPA free line of bottles coming out. They have a kid line and they are known for their durability.
    http://www.nalgenechoice.com/gripngulp.html

  17. Jen said:

    I also went on a sippy cup tossing spree recently, when I started to hear about the BPA stuff. I found some good websites that listed “safe” cups and invested in a bunch of those Nuby cups. They’re great! Even better than the other sippies we were using because they don’t have a separate plastic piece to keep them leak-free.

    Sorry your stylish Siggs didn’t work out. :(

Leave a Comment

Quicktags: